4/18/2009

I've Killed Something Beautiful

Apt and eager to take on the uncertainties of this beautiful April morning, I opened my front door and took a deep breath. Exhaling and looking out at the clear sky I felt something land on my shirt with a buzz. I instinctively brushed down with my right hand and took a step back to see a yellow jacket fall to the floor. My screen door closed as I backed into the kitchen while the wasp squirmed a bit on the floor as it flipped itself over. Having a bad experience in the past I panicked and stomped down with my right foot and twisted it counter clock-wise. I turned my head away and winced after hearing the barely audible 'crunk' as I ended the life of something beautiful.

I wouldn't say it ruined my day but it certainly put a damper on things - as I spent the rest of the day mulling over my split-second decision. The corpse is still there, right in front of my door; I'm not sure when I'll pick it up. I remember when I had absolutely no problem killing insects - I even did it for fun once in a while. I had a friend next door when I was in elementary school and we used to have a contest to see who could kill the most bumble bees in my front yard. They would hover right above the grass at exactly the right height for us to pounce at the right time and squish them under our little feet.

It's strange now that I think about it. I believe I always had a slight phobia of insects and arachnids of all sorts, but I went through phases in which I enjoyed inflicting harm on them. In another house at another location.....and yet another friend when I was five years old, we used to look around the perimeter of his house for daddy long-legs. While I just watched, he would pick them up by one leg and pluck the rest off one by one until only one remained. I didn't particularly enjoy this activity, but he was my only friend at the time.

Which brings me to ponder the importance or value of different forms of life. I remember having a discussion with my aunt not too long ago about what we would do if I hit a deer with my car. She said that depending on the severity of the injury, she would most likely try to run the deer over again to kill it, to end its misery. I honestly don't know if I could bring myself to do that. I then asked her if she would have the same attitude and willingness to accomplish something of that nature with a human being, if say perhaps there was absolutely no hope for recovery. She said she didn't know, and that it's completely different.

Is it completely different? I don't know - I suppose it depends on the person and their point of view. I killed the wasp because I was afraid it would sting me. I suppose I shouldn't feel bad about it, but I do. I've never killed a human before, but if I was defending myself and it happened, I don't think I would feel any different than killing the wasp. Sure if there was a dead human body laying in front of my kitchen door, there would be bigger implications in terms of the law, but psychologically I don't think I would react any differently. Did I cry when I killed the wasp? No. Would I cry if I killed a human out of self-defense? I don't think I would.

If you asked me if I would rather save the lives of 1000 people or 1000 bugs or 1000 elephants or 1000 deer or 1000 polar bears, I wouldn't have an answer for you. Of course the people I know and love are important to me, and so my answer to the previous question would not apply - but in general I don't think human life is more important than any other form of life. Would I be called evil? Probably. Unethical? Amoral? Filthy excuse for a human-being? Most likely. I honestly couldn't care less what people think of me, but I think its this mode of thought that is destroying the diversity and beauty of our earth. Some people would just say that its evolution - survival of the fittest....but do you think humans will evolve fast enough to keep up with drastic human-induced changes to our world? I'm not so sure.

6 comments:

  1. This is very interesting. First off, because I'm terrified of things that can sting. And secondly, because I think if you really hit a deer, you'd be lucky to get your vehicle going again. Those mofos can wreak a lotta damage on your car.

    But I'd ask ... do you have a problem with killing, say, roaches or ants if they're in your home?

    I get where you're going, as far as humans' general disregard for all other species and nature in general being responsible for a lot of this earth's troubles. But I think the difference, to me at least, is the recognition of a shared human experience. And if you whittle that down even further, it's probably why most people feel more of an emotional connection with relatives.

    We, as humans, have little in common with a wasp or a deer, and it's hard for us to bridge that gap in any meaningful way. So it's tough for us to feel the same sort of remorse when an animal dies as opposed to an uncle.

    The only exception to this theory might be domesticated animals, especially dogs and cats.

    But I dunno. Something to think about, at least.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Haha, now that I think about it - I believe my aunt was talking about a rodent of some sort and not a deer. My grandmother actually hit a deer once and put a huge dent in her front end. She called the police later and asked them how the deer was and they told her she was lucky to be alive.

    To answer your question, yes I would probably have a problem killing any sort of insect in my house. If it was bothering me I'd do what I can to relocate it outside. I actually have a few house spiders in my home that I say hi to every now and then. They don't really bother me. If I had an infestation though, I'd be forced to call an exterminator.

    I do agree with you with the shared human experience - I suppose I do feel slightly different when I hear about the death of a dog vs the death of an infant. At the same time though I don't think one life is more important than the other. I suppose I might be confusing a subjective viewpoint from an objective one, but I'm not sure. While I have more inherent compassion towards humans my actions and decision making are based on an objective viewpoint that we're all equal. I don't know if I'm right in calling that an objective viewpoint, but I say that because subjectively saying I care more for humans while thinking they're equal in significance to let's say ants seems contradictory.

    Well I hope that makes sense. I know I'm pretty confused myself.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hey Jordan,

    You should check this out sometime. I'm a fan of Imogen and I stumbled across this tonight. She did some kind of live stream piano playing...pretty great. http://www.ustream.tv/recorded/1446871

    Hope you're well!
    Jen

    ReplyDelete
  4. About choosing what to save I would choose humans.I would feel guilty about the others but I care way mroe about humans than I do animals and that's that.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Anonymous10:27 PM

    curious...
    which aunt?
    if it's the one I'm thinking....
    she doesn't care if her brother suffers for decades after decades after decades, as she's pro DNR.
    Lucky deer, being put out of misery.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Anonymous10:29 PM

    correction:
    ANTI-DNR

    ReplyDelete

Moving

 Trying out a different platform: https://museparade.wordpress.com/